Like me, you may have spent your Sunday morning watching Aaron Rodgers throw three interceptions and 22 more incomplete passes for the Jets in London. You may have seen Rodgers’ throws glide off the fingertips of almost every pass-catcher in a New York uniform as they still managed to mount a half-hearted comeback in a 23-17 loss to the undefeated Minnesota Vikings.
I wonder if Davante Adams found himself on his couch, nursing that balky hamstring, watching this same game. Maybe he was keeping tabs on his former quarterback and the team in green and white and thinking to himself, “Yeah… these are my guys. I can work with this.”
The sinking Las Vegas Raiders are apparently ready to move on from Adams, with coach Antonio Pierce adding to the drama every step of the way. Adams, who long maintained publicly that he wanted to stay in Vegas, is now open to a trade, too.
The usual insiders have reported that trade talks “should ramp up over the next 48 hours” and that Adams would prefer a landing spot with a quarterback he’s played with before — the 2-3 Jets and Rodgers, or the New Orleans Saints and Derek Carr.
The Raiders may be able to start a bidding war pitting not only the Jets and Saints, but also other interested teams against each other. After all, a star like Adams makes any team better.
But New York is hardly guaranteed to get that much better if it pulls off the move. Of the Jets’ myriad of problems, the amount of wide receiver talent ranks pretty low, for a change.
Full disclosure here: I’m a Jets fan, reasonably young but still of the “long-suffering” variety. (If you think there’s some sort of ethical problem with me writing about this team in a professional capacity, well, if Jets fan Rich Eisen was allowed to do play-by-play for the London game, I think I’m within my rights to criticize them.)
There are several points we can make in favor of a Jets trade for Adams. Rodgers and Adams have connected on 76 touchdowns between the regular season and playoffs in an eight-year marriage in Green Bay, tied for fifth most by a quarterback-receiver duo in league history. The Jets still have faint playoff hopes because the AFC East is weaker than expected, with the Buffalo Bills at 3-2 but suddenly looking vulnerable and the Miami Dolphins feeling around in the dark without a solid quarterback.
And as hard as the past few years (or decades) have been on fans of this team, just saying “we can’t have nice things” doesn’t mean you don’t try. I saw this attitude in 2020 from antagonists of the Jets as well as some supposed fans — it went like, “Why get excited about the chance to land Trevor Lawrence? We’ll just find a way to ruin him too.” I get that this organization inspires nihilism in people, but that worldview frankly sucks.
That said, the Jets aren’t one star receiver away from a Super Bowl, just as, lo and behold, they weren’t one aging future Hall of Famer at quarterback away from becoming unstoppable. Rodgers threw two of his three interceptions on Sunday in the first quarter alone, both on pretty bad decisions, not flukes or tipped balls.
The Jets already banked so much on Rodgers transforming them. They installed his preferred offensive coordinator and signed another former Packer teammate, Allen Lazard, at receiver. (Don’t forget a very washed Randall Cobb in 2023!) Then why is the guy’s cadence and timing with his teammates so clearly off, and why would one more familiar face make that disappear?
The other big issue is that coach Robert Saleh hasn’t had the Jets prepared, seen at its worst in an ugly 10-9 loss to the Denver Broncos in Week 4. So it doesn’t help when Rodgers is also utterly predictable with who he wants to throw to. He forced an unwise pass to his buddy Lazard in the red zone on Sunday before Lazard eventually scored, and he tried another extremely low-percentage shot to Tyler Conklin in double coverage at the goal line.
There’s a universe where the Jets right the ship. Maybe it’s with Adams and maybe it’s not, but most of the middle part of their schedule is eminently beatable except for the Houston Texans. Tons would have to go right — the running game has to rank better than 32nd in a 32-team league, and someone would need to wave a magic wand over an offensive line that’s barely holding things together.
Mortgaging more of your future to pair Adams with your 40-year-old quarterback doesn’t paper over those problems. And it would make ultimately missing the playoffs hurt the fans twice as much.
